The Pikes were looking to continue their unbeaten run at Huddersfield, but will now hope to continue their unbeaten run against North Yorkshire rivals Knaresborough Town on Friday night.
They were only three games in the division, but Frykley's comprehensive win against Rossington Main saw Tony Hackworth's side drop one place to 14th.
Back at Ryedale, Amasabee & Swinton's Victory Cup at home against Goal Sports on the Malton 3G pitch was the only game to survive the rainy and windy weather.
The hosts got off to a great start and took the lead midway through the first half with Oscar Johnston replacing Josh Towse.
However, Amazabi was unable to take advantage of the situation in the second half and allowed their opponent to continue playing.
The hosts looked truly dead and buried when Brad Cawkwell equalized just before the half-hour mark and Connor Myerscough put the Scarborough side ahead from the penalty spot.
There was still time for late drama, however, as Adam Stockel headed home from Jake Jordan's corner kick in stoppage time to ensure they shared the spoils.